Forever BiS

Best gear at level 60, from items proven to exist in WoW Forever.

Protection Warrior best in slot (Alliance, level 60)

As of 16 Nov 2026 (game build 1.60.1.70938), the best weapons for an Alliance Protection Warrior at level 60 in WoW Forever are Scaleguard Scimitar in the main hand, whose source is not known yet, and Intricately Runed Shield in the off hand, which drops from Ras Frostwhisper (Scholomance). Blackrock Spire holds the most picks of any dungeon or raid: 9 items (shoulder, chest, hands, waist, legs, feet, finger). Every pick is an item the game's own data proves exists, ranked by stat weights measured by a simulator.

Ranked by wowsims Pre-BiS (Defense Cap) (warrior/protection), stat weights measured by a simulator · Game data from 16 Nov 2026

Most picks in one instance: Blackrock Spire, 9 items (shoulder, chest, hands, waist, legs, feet, finger).

No luck needed: 11 items from vendors, quests, reputation and crafting.

Open world: 1 item in Azshara.

Best items per slot for Protection Warrior, Alliance

Tick what you already have: the lines above and "Where to get them" then count only your upgrades.

Head

  1. best
    Set bonus not counted
    score 66.2
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Darkmaster Gandling · +1 more source
    Location: Scholomance, dungeon
  2. 2nd
    Lead: probably a drop
    score 58.6
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
  3. 3rd
    score 57.8
    Top 3 only by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Defense Cap)
    Source: Balnazzar · +1 more source
    Location: Stratholme, dungeon
Harder to get (4)
  • Epic, hard to get: 2245 · Bind on equip, no known source · would be 4th · score 64.6, from the released table
  • Random roll: 14979 · One of 32 random rolls · would be 12th · score 54.1, from the released table
  • Class set, hard to get before raids: 21999 (Battlegear of Heroism) · would be best · score 76.4, from the unconfirmed table
  • PvP reward: 16478 · score 91.4

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Neck

  1. best
    score 19.6
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Aurius' Reckoning [5125] · +1 more source
    Location: Quest
  2. 2nd
    score 17.8
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Emperor Dagran Thaurissan · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Depths, dungeon
  3. 3rd
    score 17.8
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
Harder to get (4)
  • Epic, hard to get: 20622 · No known source · would be best · score 30.6, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 12048 · One of 35 random rolls · would be best · score 20.6, from the released table
  • Reputation grind: 271917 (Theramore Expeditionary Force, Honored) · would be 10th · score 17.3, from the listed table
  • PvP reward: 19097 · score 22.1

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Shoulder

  1. best
    score 54.1
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
  2. 2nd
    Set bonus not counted
    score 50.8
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Warchief Rend Blackhand · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Spire, dungeon
  3. 3rd
    score 50.3
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Princess Moira Bronzebeard · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Depths, dungeon
Harder to get (5)
  • Epic, hard to get: 14552 · Bind on equip, no known source · would be 13th · score 44.1, from the released table
  • Random roll: 10390 · One of 32 random rolls · would be 12th · score 44.3, from the released table
  • Reputation grind: 271959 (Theramore Expeditionary Force, Exalted) · would be best · score 66.8, from the released table
  • Class set, hard to get before raids: 226858 (Battlegear of Heroism) · would be 2nd · score 55.9, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 16480 · score 71.4

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Back

  1. best
    score 28.4
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Stonespine · +1 more source
    Location: Stratholme, dungeon
  2. 2nd
    score 26.5
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Epic kept in the ranking: realistic to get (BoP, rep/vendor) · Known from a developer hotfix, not yet seen on a player
    Source: The League of Arathor (Exalted) · +2 more sources
    Location: Reputation
  3. 3rd
    score 25.6
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
Harder to get (4)
  • Epic, hard to get: 279269 · Bind on equip · would be best · score 26.6, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 10249 · One of 41 random rolls · would be 15th · score 20.5, from the released table
  • Reputation grind: 271907 (Theramore Expeditionary Force, Honored) · would be 127th · score 11.0, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 16342 · score 24.1

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Chest

  1. best
    score 81.0
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Epic kept in the ranking: realistic to get (BoP, quest)
    Source: Breastplate of the Chromatic Flight [5166] · +1 more source
    Location: Quest
  2. 2nd
    Set bonus not counted
    score 68.5
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: General Drakkisath · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Spire, dungeon
  3. 3rd
    score 65.4
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: In Dreams [5944] · +1 more source
    Location: Quest
Harder to get (4)
  • Epic, hard to get: 22196 · Bind on equip · would be best · score 74.5, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 10384 · One of 32 random rolls · would be 6th · score 60.7, from the listed table
  • Class set, hard to get before raids: 226872 (Battlegear of Heroism) · would be 2nd · score 80.2, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 16477 · score 96.5

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Wrist

  1. best
    Set bonus not counted
    score 37.5
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Deliana (Alliance) · +3 more sources
    Location: Ironforge, vendor
  2. 2nd
    Set bonus not counted
    score 37.4
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Deliana (Alliance) · +3 more sources
    Location: Ironforge, vendor
  3. 3rd
    score 34.7
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Darkmaster Gandling · +1 more source
    Location: Scholomance, dungeon
Harder to get (3)
  • Epic, hard to get: 21584 · No known source · would be best · score 46.5, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 10391 · One of 32 random rolls · would be 12th · score 28.9, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 16481 · score 46.7

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Hands

  1. best
    score 46.1
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Overlord Wyrmthalak · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Spire, dungeon
  2. 2nd
    score 44.9
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Ras Frostwhisper
    Location: Scholomance, dungeon
  3. 3rd
    score 41.8
    Top 3 only by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Defense Cap)
    Known from a developer hotfix, not yet seen on a player
    Source: Blacksmithing
    Location: Crafted
Harder to get (5)
  • Epic, hard to get: 279264 · Bind on equip · would be 2nd · score 50.2, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 10386 · One of 32 random rolls · would be 10th · score 39.9, from the released table
  • Reputation grind: 271940 (Theramore Expeditionary Force, Exalted) · would be best · score 58.3, from the listed table
  • Class set, hard to get before raids: 226861 (Battlegear of Heroism) · would be best · score 49.1, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 16484 · score 66.3

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Waist

  1. best
    score 44.4
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: General Drakkisath · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Spire, dungeon
  2. 2nd
    score 44.4
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Goraluk Anvilcrack · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Spire, dungeon
  3. 3rd
    Set bonus not counted
    score 41.1
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Trash · +5 more sources
    Location: Blackrock Spire, dungeon
Harder to get (4)
  • Epic, hard to get: 19163 · Bind on equip · would be 9th · score 38.0, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 10387 · One of 32 random rolls · would be 7th · score 38.3, from the released table
  • Class set, hard to get before raids: 226866 (Battlegear of Heroism) · would be best · score 48.1, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 272791 · score 62.3

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Legs

  1. best
    score 72.5
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Goraluk Anvilcrack · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Spire, dungeon
  2. 2nd
    Set bonus not counted
    score 70.2
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Baron Rivendare · +1 more source
    Location: Stratholme, dungeon
  3. 3rd
    Lead: probably a drop
    score 65.6
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
Harder to get (4)
  • Epic, hard to get: 279265 · Bind on equip · would be best · score 81.3, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 10389 · One of 32 random rolls · would be 12th · score 55.6, from the released table
  • Class set, hard to get before raids: 226868 (Battlegear of Heroism) · would be best · score 76.1, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 16479 · score 86.9

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Feet

  1. best
    score 50.9
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Urok Doomhowl · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Spire, dungeon
  2. 2nd
    score 49.1
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
  3. 3rd
    Set bonus not counted
    score 48.6
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Kirtonos the Herald · +1 more source
    Location: Scholomance, dungeon
Harder to get (4)
  • Epic, hard to get: 279263 · Bind on equip · would be best · score 53.1, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 14978 · One of 32 random rolls · would be 12th · score 42.8, from the released table
  • Class set, hard to get before raids: 226871 (Battlegear of Heroism) · would be best · score 57.0, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 16483 · score 69.1

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Finger · wear 2

  1. best
    score 43.8
    Also top 6 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Epic kept in the ranking: realistic to get (BoP, rep) · Known from a developer hotfix, not yet seen on a player
    Source: The Watchers (Exalted)
    Location: Reputation
  2. 2nd
    score 25.3
    Also top 6 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Ramstein the Gorger · +1 more source
    Location: Stratholme, dungeon
  3. 3rd
    score 23.6
    Also top 6 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: King Gordok · +1 more source
    Location: Dire Maul, dungeon
  4. 4th
    score 23.3
    Also top 6 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
  5. 5th
    score 21.0
    Also top 6 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Ezra Grimm
    Location: Stratholme, dungeon
  6. 6th
    score 19.8
    Top 6 only by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Defense Cap)
    Source: General Drakkisath · +1 more source
    Location: Blackrock Spire, dungeon
Harder to get (3)
  • Epic, hard to get: 284716 · No known source · would be best · score 48.2, from the released table
  • Random roll: 12017 · One of 35 random rolls · would be 13th · score 20.6, from the released table
  • Reputation grind: 271908 (Theramore Expeditionary Force, Honored) · would be 11th · score 23.0, from the listed table

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Trinket · wear 2

  1. best
    Special effect not counted
    score 23.4
    Also top 4 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Known from a developer hotfix, not yet seen on a player
    Source: Pix Xizzix · +1 more source
    Location: Stranglethorn Vale, vendor
  2. 2nd
    score 18.6
    Also top 4 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Codex of Defense [7499] · +1 more source
    Location: Quest
  3. 3rd
    Special effect not counted
    score 10.3
    Also top 4 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
  4. 4th
    Special effect not counted
    score 10.3
    Also top 4 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Into The Temple of Atal'Hakkar [1475] (Alliance) · +1 more source
    Location: Quest
Harder to get (3)
  • Epic, hard to get: 14557 · Bind on equip · would be 17th · score 1.8, from the released table
  • Reputation grind: 271903 (Theramore Expeditionary Force, Friendly) · would be 3rd · score 11.5, from the listed table
  • PvP reward: 18854 · score 0.0

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Main hand

  1. best
    Lead: probably a drop
    score 73.4
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
  2. 2nd
    Lead: probably a drop
    score 71.2
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source and location: Not known yet
  3. 3rd
    score 71.1
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Prince Tortheldrin · +1 more source
    Location: Dire Maul, dungeon
Harder to get (4)
  • Epic, hard to get: 17142 · No known source · would be best · score 188.2, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 15221 · One of 35 random rolls · would be 15th · score 64.9, from the released table
  • Reputation grind: 271936 (Theramore Expeditionary Force, Revered) · would be 4th · score 70.7, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 18838 · score 97.9

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Off hand

  1. best
    score 108.3
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Ras Frostwhisper
    Location: Scholomance, dungeon
  2. 2nd
    score 108.1
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Avalanchion
    Location: Azshara, open world
  3. 3rd
    score 103.3
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Withermaw
    Location: Zone not known
Harder to get (3)
  • Epic, hard to get: 279262 · Bind on equip · would be best · score 123.3, from the listed table
  • Random roll: 10271 · One of 34 random rolls · would be 9th · score 98.5, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 18825 · score 149.8

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Ranged

  1. best
    score 13.1
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Cannon Master Willey · +1 more source
    Location: Stratholme, dungeon
  2. 2nd
    score 13.0
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Nerub'enkan · +1 more source
    Location: Stratholme, dungeon
  3. 3rd
    score 10.1
    Also top 3 by wowsims Protection Pre-BiS (Threat)
    Source: Nekrum Gutchewer · +1 more source
    Location: Zul'Farrak, dungeon
Harder to get (3)
  • Epic, hard to get: 284587 · Bind on equip, no known source · would be best · score 13.6, from the released table
  • Random roll: 15289 · One of 25 random rolls · would be 4th · score 12.0, from the released table
  • PvP reward: 272841 · score 15.5

Never picks, shown to compare. "Would be 2nd" is its place among the picks had it been ranked.

Notes on the picks

  • Finger: Watcher's Signet of Vigilance (275980), 41.5, is not a pick: it shares the limit category "Watcher's Ring" with Warden's Signet of Vigilance (275984), and only 1 can be worn.
  • Finger: Tracker's Signet of Vigilance (275975), 38.9, is not a pick: it shares the limit category "Watcher's Ring" with Warden's Signet of Vigilance (275984), and only 1 can be worn.
  • Finger: Initiate's Signet of Vigilance (275971), 34.1, is not a pick: it shares the limit category "Watcher's Ring" with Warden's Signet of Vigilance (275984), and only 1 can be worn.
  • Finger: Warden's Signet of Ferocity (275981), 25.6, is not a pick: it shares the limit category "Watcher's Ring" with Warden's Signet of Vigilance (275984), and only 1 can be worn.
  • Finger: Watcher's Signet of Ferocity (275976), 23.4, is not a pick: it shares the limit category "Watcher's Ring" with Warden's Signet of Vigilance (275984), and only 1 can be worn.
  • Finger: Warden's Signet of Brilliance (275982), 20.0, is not a pick: it shares the limit category "Watcher's Ring" with Warden's Signet of Vigilance (275984), and only 1 can be worn.

Where to get them

Counts the items that can drop or be had there, not their drop chances. An item with several sources counts at each.

Blackrock Spire dungeon · 9 items

Stratholme dungeon · 8 items

Scholomance dungeon · 5 items

Blackrock Depths dungeon · 2 items

Dire Maul dungeon · 2 items

Zul'Farrak dungeon · 1 item

Sold by Deliana (Dun Morogh) 2 items

Sold by Deliana, Ironforge Guard (Ironforge) 2 items

Quest: Aurius' Reckoning [5125] 1 item

Quest: Breastplate of the Chromatic Flight [5166] 1 item

Reputation: The Watchers 1 item

Sold by Pix Xizzix (Stranglethorn Vale) 1 item

Crafted: Blacksmithing 1 item

Quest: Codex of Defense [7499] 1 item

Quest: In Dreams [5944] 1 item

Quest: Into The Temple of Atal'Hakkar [1475] (Alliance) 1 item

Reputation: The League of Arathor 1 item

Sold by Samuel Hawke (Arathi Highlands) 1 item

Azshara open world · 1 item

Zone not known

Source not known yet

About this list

How to read it

Each slot lists the strongest items for this spec that the game has released, in rank order: 1 is the best, then 2 and 3 (4 for trinkets, 6 for rings; you wear two of each). Each comes with the one most useful place to get it: Source is who or what gives it, Location is where. "Set bonus not counted" and "Special effect not counted" mean the rank ignores part of the item: judge those yourself. "Show details" adds the scores, simulation results, item ids and the method notes.

"Harder to get" under a slot holds what is never a pick, shown to compare: the best epic that is hard to get (bind on equip, no known source, or a world drop only), the best random-roll item (a specific "of the ..." roll is one of several), the best item of a reputation too hard to earn before the raids open, the best piece of a class set too hard to get before the raids open (its bracers stay picks), and the best PvP rank reward.

How the picks are chosen

The best 3 items per slot (4 for trinkets, 6 for rings; both are worn twice) this profile can equip at level 60, from the items the server has released: epic and random-roll alternatives, gear of a reputation too hard to earn before the raids open, class-set pieces too hard to get before the raids open (the bracers stay), PvP rank rewards and items left out (closed raid, other class, other faction) are never picks (the best alternatives are listed below). In a slot worn twice, items sharing an item limit category (only that many can be worn, e.g. the Watchers' signets) count once: the best is picked, the others are noted. Each pick: name (id), score, How, the one most useful source this character can use, the robustness flag ("also top 3 under" the second scale, or "only under" the primary one), and flags: "epic kept: realistic" (an epic the epic rule keeps ranked), "hotfixed only" (evidence is a designer hotfix, not a reveal), "source unknown" / "source likely" (only leads), "effect not scored" / "set bonus not scored" (the score ignores equip effects, procs and set bonuses: check them).

Stat weights

Scale: wowsims Pre-BiS (Defense Cap) (warrior/protection), grade A, simulator-measured (wowsims/forever presets (warrior/protection, EP preset 'Pre-BiS (Defense Cap)'), checkout bbd06d52f519 in data/wowsims-src (read-only); level 60, raid-buffed; method in the file: measured on the Pre-BiS gear: 0.6 x threat weights (Strength = 1) + 1.15 x TMI weights (Stamina = 1); defense past the cap; hit past the 8% cap). Robustness flags against a second scale: wowsims Pre-BiS (Threat) (warrior/protection), grade A, simulator-measured. Static score: equip effects, procs and set bonuses are NOT valued (flagged on the picks).

Data

Data: build 1.60.1.70938, raidbots/20261116-031625 (remote; Last-Modified 2026-11-16T03:05:54; no Hotfix.log).

Your ticks

Your ticks are stored only in this browser and never sent anywhere. They are shared by the specs of one class and faction. "Clear my ticks" or clearing this site's data removes them.